Naomi Cockafair (née Hendershott)
c. 1767
Naomi Cockafair was born Naomi Hendershott, a twin sister of Mary Hendershott. In July 1778, when the two girls were eleven, their family was killed during the Wyoming Valley massacre near present-day Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania; the twins hid behind a log and escaped with a few others to the Delaware River settlements. They afterwards came to Bloomfield, where Mary married Thomas Cockefair and Naomi married John Cockefair. Naomi lived until 1835 and was known in the neighbourhood as 'Aunt Nomie'; her house stood on Broad Street at Stone House Plains, just north of what later became 741 Broad Street.
Sources (2)
- Gravestone inscription: mother of Isaac
Inscription on the stone, photographed by an Epitaph visitor on 2026-10-03.Isaac is named son of John and Naomi Cockafair. - Bloomfield, Old and New: An Historical Symposium: maiden name, Wyoming massacre survival, death year, nickname
Joseph F. Folsom (ed.), 'Bloomfield, Old and New: An Historical Symposium' (Bloomfield Centennial Historical Committee, 1912), 'The Annals of Stone House Plains' and ch. 1, pp. 15, 173-174.Mary and Naomi Hendershott, eleven-year-old twins, hid behind a log during the July 1778 Wyoming massacre and escaped; Thomas Cockefair married Mary and a John Cockefair married Naomi; Mary lived until 1808 and Naomi until 1835, the latter known as 'Aunt Nomie', her home standing near 741 Broad Street.
Isaac Cockafair
c. November 1786 – August 2, 1803
Isaac Cockafair died on 2 August 1803 at the age of sixteen years, eight months and seven days, which places his birth late in 1786. His stone names him as a son of John and Naomi Cockafair, of the Dutch-descended Cockefair family long settled at Stone House Plains (later Brookdale) in Bloomfield. His mother Naomi was a survivor of the 1778 Wyoming Valley massacre in Pennsylvania.
Sources (2)
- Gravestone inscription: death date, age and parentage
Inscription on the stone, photographed by an Epitaph visitor on 2026-10-03.The stone records Isaac Cockafair, son of John and Naomi Cockafair, died 2 August 1803, aged 16 years, 8 months and 7 days. - Bloomfield, Old and New: An Historical Symposium: family context
Joseph F. Folsom (ed.), 'Bloomfield, Old and New: An Historical Symposium' (Bloomfield Centennial Historical Committee, 1912), 'The Annals of Stone House Plains' and ch. 1, pp. 15, 173-174.The Cockefairs are named among the Dutch families who founded Stone House Plains in the Bloomfield area; a John Cockefair married Naomi Hendershott.
John Cockafair (also spelled Cockefair) belonged to one of the Dutch families of Stone House Plains, now Brookdale, in Bloomfield. He married Naomi Hendershott, a survivor of the Wyoming Valley massacre of 1778, and their home stood on what is now Broad Street. A John Cockafair appears as a head of household in the Essex County listings of 1793. Bloomfield's local historians were careful to distinguish him from a later John Cockefair, son of Thomas Cockefair and Mary Hendershott, who built at 901 Broad Street in 1817.
Sources (3)
- Gravestone inscription: father of Isaac
Inscription on the stone, photographed by an Epitaph visitor on 2026-10-03.Isaac is named son of John and Naomi Cockafair. - Bloomfield, Old and New: An Historical Symposium: marriage and residence
Joseph F. Folsom (ed.), 'Bloomfield, Old and New: An Historical Symposium' (Bloomfield Centennial Historical Committee, 1912), 'The Annals of Stone House Plains' and ch. 1, pp. 15, 173-174.A John Cockefair married Naomi Hendershott; their home stood on Broad Street at Stone House Plains, and he is distinguished from the John Cockefair who was son of Thomas and Mary Hendershott. - New Jersey in 1793 (tax/census abstracts): residence in Essex County in 1793
James S. Norton, 'New Jersey in 1793', entries for Cockafair, John (p. 148) and index.John Cockafair is listed among Essex County householders in the 1793 enumeration.
Researched by Bill Blair
Photograph another stoneSpot a mistake, or something about your family that should be hidden? Report a mistake